Evolution of the ‘Prims’ (Review in The Methodist Recorder)
ALTHOUGH we are well and wisely advised not to judge a book by its cover, the central argument of David Young’s latest book on Primitive Methodism, Change and Decay. Primitive Methodism from Late Victorian Times till World War I (Tentmaker Publications, £6.50), can fairly be deduced from its title. Mr Young sets out to show how Primitive Methodism moved from being one of the most theologically conservative denominations in mid-Victorian Britain to being one of the most liberal by the early 20th century, and he argues that this alteration (“change”) coincided with, or caused, a decline in evangelistic effectiveness and spiritual power (“decay”). Having sketched Primitive Methodism “before the changes” in the opening chapter, he sets the scene by describing the theological developments and challenges of the 19th century, noting the impact of geology, evolution and the so-called “higher criticism” of the Bible on the British Churches and the turn away from the preaching of eternal punishment and a substitutionary atonement to a greater focus on God’s love. He then explores how new attitudes to the Bible, death and judgment, the atonement, the character of God, human nature and entire sanctification found their way into Primitive Methodism from the 1890s, particularly through the influence and teaching of John Day Thompson and A S Peake. Widely Mr Young has read widely in the literature of the period, as well as in more recent scholarship, and his quotations from books, periodicals and newspapers are as instructive and thought-provoking as his argument is clear and trenchant. Change and Decay amply demonstrates the widening spectrum of opinions held within late Victorian and Edwardian Primitive Methodism, and shows both how far some had accommodated to “modern thought” and how strongly others resisted it. The section quoting jeremiads about spiritual decline from as early as the 1860s – long before any flirtation with Darwinism, higher criticism or the “larger hope” – might give pause to those inclined to trace every “decay” directly to a departure from ultra-conservative orthodoxy, and this reviewer would demur at describing Peake’s approach as “at best self-deception … at worst dishonesty” (page 287). This is an informed and informative study of an important subject and to have another book on the long-neglected Prims to set alongside Sandy Calder’s The Origins of Primitive Methodism is very welcome – and especially at such an affordable price!
The Rev Dr Martin Wellings is superintendent minister of the Oxford circuit.
There has been a gap in our knowledge of Primitive Methodist theology in the later period of the movement. David Young has now produced a detailed and informative account, concluding that there was for more drastic theological change than has been supposed but also (and this is where the author’s sympathies lie) that there was a great deal of grassroots doctrinal conservatism. David Bebbington, Professor of History, University of Stirling
David Young has undertaken very extensive study of primary sources in Primitive Methodism. He has produced a book which offers detailed analysis of a range of theological issues within the movement. Those interested in Primitive Methodist life in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century period will find that Young’s work probes areas illuminatingly that have not previously received this kind of coverage. Dr Ian Randall, Senior Research Fellow, Spurgeon’s College, London
David Young’s study of late nineteenth-century Primitive Methodism breaks new ground in exploring the nature and impact of changes in the denomination. His detailed research and trenchant opinions will stimulate further work on an important subject. Rev Dr Martin Wellings, Superintendent Minister, Oxford Methodist Circuit
Very interesting … fascinating and explains a lot. The sad decline in theological certainty in the churches is expertly documented in David Young’s work. Pastor Richard White-Watts, Independent Primitive Methodist Chapel, Lowdham]